LINA
Why the Scale Goes Up Even in a Calorie Deficit
Understand why the scale going up in calorie deficit is common, and why weight increases while dieting can still mean fat loss.
Last updated: 2026-01-14
Fat mass vs total body weight
The scale measures total body weight, not just fat. It includes water, glycogen, food volume in the gut, and temporary fluid shifts.
Fat loss is slow. A typical rate is 0.25 to 0.75 kg per week, which can be hidden by normal day to day water changes.
Why the scale can rise even when fat loss is happening
The most common reason for a scale going up in calorie deficit is water retention. This is why weight increases while dieting even when fat loss continues.
A salty meal, higher carbs, or a hard workout can add water without adding fat. Fat loss can happen while scale weight increases because water shifts faster than fat tissue.
Carbs refill glycogen, and glycogen holds water. Sodium pulls water into the body. Training soreness creates local inflammation that also holds fluid.
Stress and poor sleep increase cortisol and can make the body retain water. Hormone shifts, especially around the menstrual cycle, can do the same.
A real example: up 1 kg overnight
You ate on plan, trained, and woke up 1 kg heavier. That is frustrating, but it is almost always water, not fat.
Gaining 1 kg of fat would require a large calorie surplus across several days. If your logs are accurate, the math does not support true fat gain.
When weight gain is a real problem vs when it is not
It is a real issue when your 7 to 14 day average is rising for 2 to 3 weeks, your calorie logs show consistent overages, and measurements or clothes are also trending up.
It is usually not a problem when the spike follows high sodium meals, higher carbs, travel, a hard training block, poor sleep, or a known hormone phase.
FAQ
Can I gain fat while eating in a deficit?
Not if the deficit is real. Most short term gains are water or food volume, but inaccurate tracking can erase the deficit.
Do carbs cause fat gain while dieting?
Carbs increase water and glycogen, which can raise scale weight, but fat gain still requires a calorie surplus.
When should I lower calories?
Only after the weekly trend is flat or rising for 2 to 3 weeks, not after a single weigh in.
Track trends, not single weigh ins
Daily weigh ins are useful, but the trend is what matters. A 7 day average smooths the noise and shows real progress.
If your trend is down or stable, keep your plan. Adjust only when the average tells a consistent story.
LINA landing sections
Related tracker pages
Put this into action with LINA
LINA tracks daily weight and shows the trend so you can focus on the signal. LINA app to keep calories, macros, and habits in one place.